I used to use the Surround Green back before Encap green existed. I liked the smell quite a bit. Didn't like that it dried to more of a firm shell than an "expand and shatter" type, but from what I gather that is by design and some argue that it is better. Worked as well as encap green, don't know about resoil rate. I switched to EG mainly because the EG has deodorizing properties. The surround free is an interesting concept, suitable for use in the ultra sensitive such as the homes where I currently use Quantum Green. I haven't tried any of the others.